Find Cars for Sale and Dealers near Kiamesha Lake, NY 12751

Top 20 Best Deals near Kiamesha Lake

Great deal

Used 2024 Nissan Versa S

Pre-Owned 2024 Nissan Versa S
Price: $16,499 Port Jervis Auto Mall
Seller: Port Jervis Auto Mall  
Color: Silver
Mileage: 3,844
Trans: CVT
$1,056 below avg of $17,555
21,997 miles below avg of 25,841
VIN:
3N1CN8DV8RL911232
Type:
Used
Engine:
I4
MPG:
--
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
20 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
Cloth
Body Style:
Sedan
Drivetrain:
FWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
131-139 Kingston Avenue, Port Jervis, New York 12771
Last indexed: 2/10/2026
Great deal

Used 2025 Chevrolet Trax LS

Pre-Owned 2025 Chevrolet Trax LS
Price: $20,449 Kia of Middletown
Seller: Kia of Middletown  
Color: Gray
Mileage: 2,956
Trans: Automatic
$604 below avg of $21,053
15,580 miles below avg of 18,536
VIN:
KL77LFEP7SC021800
Type:
Used
Engine:
I3
MPG:
28 / 32
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
23 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
Wagon
Drivetrain:
FWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
4961 New York 17M, New Hampton, New York 10958
Last indexed: 2/5/2026
Great deal

Certified 2024 Toyota Highlander XLE

Certified Pre-Owned 2024 Toyota Highlander XLE
Price: $42,988 Johnstons Toyota
Seller: Johnstons Toyota  
Color: Black
Mileage: 3,282
Trans: Automatic
$2,291 above avg of $40,697
29,442 miles below avg of 32,724
VIN:
5TDKDRBH4RS564345
Type:
Certified
Engine:
I4
MPG:
21 / 28
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
23 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
SUV
Drivetrain:
AWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
5021 New York 17M, New Hampton, New York 10958
Last indexed: 2/6/2026
Great deal

Used 2023 Dodge Hornet GT

Pre-Owned 2023 Dodge Hornet GT
Price: $19,353 HEALEY MITSUBISHI
Seller: HEALEY MITSUBISHI  
Color: --
Mileage: 12,093
Trans: Automatic
$5,543 below avg of $24,896
15,495 miles below avg of 27,588
VIN:
ZACNDFAN4P3A03616
Type:
Used
Engine:
I4
MPG:
--
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
21 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
Wagon
Drivetrain:
AWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
243 Dolson Avenue, Middletown, New York 10940
Last indexed: 2/6/2026
Great deal

Used 2024 Jeep Compass Limited

Pre-Owned 2024 Jeep Compass Limited
Price: $27,699 Port Jervis Auto Mall
Seller: Port Jervis Auto Mall  
Color: Black
Mileage: 3,689
Trans: Automatic
$2,794 above avg of $24,905
25,647 miles below avg of 29,336
VIN:
3C4NJDCN4RT174879
Type:
Used
Engine:
I4
MPG:
--
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
20 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
SUV
Drivetrain:
4WD
Cabin:
--
Address:
131-139 Kingston Avenue, Port Jervis, New York 12771
Last indexed: 2/10/2026
Great deal

Used 2023 Ram 2500 Rebel

Pre-Owned 2023 Ram 2500 Rebel
Price: $67,499 Port Jervis Auto Mall
Seller: Port Jervis Auto Mall  
Color: Blue
Mileage: 10,000
Trans: Automatic
$1,402 above avg of $66,097
33,972 miles below avg of 43,972
VIN:
3C6UR5EL7PG616475
Type:
Used
Engine:
I6
MPG:
--
Fuel:
Diesel
Bed:
Short
Distance:
20 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
Truck
Drivetrain:
4WD
Cabin:
Crew
Address:
131-139 Kingston Avenue, Port Jervis, New York 12771
Last indexed: 2/10/2026
Great deal

Used 2025 Toyota Grand Highlander LE

Pre-Owned 2025 Toyota Grand Highlander LE
Price: $42,888 Johnstons Toyota
Seller: Johnstons Toyota  
Color: --
Mileage: 3,097
Trans: Automatic
$570 below avg of $43,458
8,582 miles below avg of 11,679
VIN:
5TDAAAA53SS031115
Type:
Used
Engine:
I4
MPG:
21 / 28
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
23 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
SUV
Drivetrain:
FWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
5021 New York 17M, New Hampton, New York 10958
Last indexed: 2/9/2026
Great deal

Certified 2025 Toyota Highlander XLE

Certified Pre-Owned 2025 Toyota Highlander XLE
Price: $44,483 Johnstons Toyota
Seller: Johnstons Toyota  
Color: Gray
Mileage: 3,605
Trans: Automatic
$2,011 above avg of $42,472
13,723 miles below avg of 17,328
VIN:
5TDKDRBH8SS583177
Type:
Certified
Engine:
I4
MPG:
21 / 28
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
23 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
SUV
Drivetrain:
AWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
5021 New York 17M, New Hampton, New York 10958
Last indexed: 2/5/2026
Great deal

Used 2025 Chrysler Pacifica Select

Pre-Owned 2025 Chrysler Pacifica Select
Price: $33,999 Port Jervis Auto Mall
Seller: Port Jervis Auto Mall  
Color: White
Mileage: 6,874
Trans: Automatic
$1,845 above avg of $32,154
27,607 miles below avg of 34,481
VIN:
2C4RC1BG2SR587471
Type:
Used
Engine:
V6
MPG:
--
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
20 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
Cloth
Body Style:
Minivan
Drivetrain:
FWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
131-139 Kingston Avenue, Port Jervis, New York 12771
Last indexed: 2/10/2026
Great deal

Used 2022 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid XLE Premium

Pre-Owned 2022 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid XLE Premium
Price: $31,998 Lexus of Orange County
Seller: Lexus of Orange County  
Color: Red
Mileage: 11,925
Trans: CVT
$1,732 above avg of $30,266
47,375 miles below avg of 59,300
VIN:
JTMB6RFV9ND533513
Type:
Used
Engine:
I4
MPG:
41 / 38
Fuel:
Gas/Electric Hybrid
Bed:
--
Distance:
22 mi
Interior Color:
Brown
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
SUV
Drivetrain:
AWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
3496 U.S. 6, Middletown, New York 10940
Last indexed: 2/4/2026
Great deal

Certified 2023 Jeep Gladiator Sport S

Certified Pre-Owned 2023 Jeep Gladiator Sport S
Price: $30,516 HEALEY MITSUBISHI
Seller: HEALEY MITSUBISHI  
Color: Silver
Mileage: 10,415
Trans: Automatic
$1,747 below avg of $32,263
22,347 miles below avg of 32,762
VIN:
1C6HJTAG9PL562024
Type:
Certified
Engine:
V6
MPG:
--
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
Short
Distance:
21 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
Truck
Drivetrain:
4WD
Cabin:
Crew
Address:
243 Dolson Avenue, Middletown, New York 10940
Last indexed: 2/4/2026
Great deal

Certified 2024 Subaru Crosstrek Premium

Certified Pre-Owned 2024 Subaru Crosstrek Premium
Price: $27,990 Johnstons Subaru
Seller: Johnstons Subaru  
Color: Gray
Mileage: 3,752
Trans: CVT
$2,367 above avg of $25,623
17,748 miles below avg of 21,500
VIN:
JF2GUADC4R8859315
Type:
Certified
Engine:
H4
MPG:
--
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
22 mi
Interior Color:
Gray
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
Wagon
Drivetrain:
AWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
3480 U.S. 6, Middletown, New York 10940
Last indexed: 2/7/2026
Great deal

Used 2025 Toyota 4Runner SR5

Pre-Owned 2025 Toyota 4Runner SR5
Price: $45,263 Johnstons Toyota
Seller: Johnstons Toyota  
Color: --
Mileage: 3,232
Trans: Automatic
$619 above avg of $44,644
9,529 miles below avg of 12,761
VIN:
JTEVA5BR2S5048628
Type:
Used
Engine:
I4
MPG:
19 / 25
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
23 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
SUV
Drivetrain:
4WD
Cabin:
--
Address:
5021 New York 17M, New Hampton, New York 10958
Last indexed: 2/9/2026
Great deal

Used 2025 Toyota Grand Highlander LE

Pre-Owned 2025 Toyota Grand Highlander LE
Price: $41,789 Johnstons Toyota
Seller: Johnstons Toyota  
Color: --
Mileage: 3,568
Trans: Automatic
$1,669 below avg of $43,458
8,111 miles below avg of 11,679
VIN:
5TDAAAA5XSS029099
Type:
Used
Engine:
I4
MPG:
21 / 28
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
23 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
SUV
Drivetrain:
FWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
5021 New York 17M, New Hampton, New York 10958
Last indexed: 2/3/2026
Great deal

Certified 2025 Nissan Altima 2.5 SV

Certified Pre-Owned 2025 Nissan Altima 2.5 SV
Price: $21,799 Kia of Middletown
Seller: Kia of Middletown  
Color: Maroon
Mileage: 5,277
Trans: CVT
$217 above avg of $21,582
15,021 miles below avg of 20,298
VIN:
1N4BL4DV8SN393061
Type:
Certified
Engine:
I4
MPG:
27 / 39
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
23 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
Sedan
Drivetrain:
FWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
4961 New York 17M, New Hampton, New York 10958
Last indexed: 2/5/2026
Great deal

Used 2023 Toyota Highlander Hybrid Limited

Pre-Owned 2023 Toyota Highlander Hybrid Limited
Price: $47,967 Johnstons Toyota
Seller: Johnstons Toyota  
Color: Green
Mileage: 8,054
Trans: CVT
$4,446 above avg of $43,521
39,940 miles below avg of 47,994
VIN:
5TDXBRCH3PS578423
Type:
Used
Engine:
I4
MPG:
35 / 34
Fuel:
Gas/Electric Hybrid
Bed:
--
Distance:
23 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
SUV
Drivetrain:
AWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
5021 New York 17M, New Hampton, New York 10958
Last indexed: 2/6/2026

Local Dealers

Search for Vehicles in Kiamesha Lake, NY 12751