Find Cars for Sale and Dealers near Shelter Island, NY 11964
Top 20 Best Deals near Shelter Island
|
Great deal
Used 2026 Volvo EX30 Ultra Twin Motor Performance, Fully electric |
|||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||
$1,350 below avg of $50,840
15 miles below avg of 17
15 miles below avg of 17
VIN:
YV4EK3ZL5T2617995
Type:
Used
Engine:
Electric
MPG:
--
Fuel:
Electric
Bed:
--
Distance:
24 mi
Interior Color:
Blue
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
SUV
Drivetrain:
AWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
575 Broad Street, New London, Connecticut 06320
Last indexed: 4/10/2026
|
Great deal
Certified 2025 Mercedes-Benz GLA GLA 250 4MATIC |
|||||||||||
|
|
|
||||||||||
$1,570 above avg of $40,938
8,268 miles below avg of 8,923
8,268 miles below avg of 8,923
VIN:
W1N4N4HB7SJ698161
Type:
Certified
Engine:
I4
MPG:
25 / 33
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
12 mi
Interior Color:
Beige
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
SUV
Drivetrain:
AWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
575 County Road 39, Southampton, New York 11968
Last indexed: 4/13/2026
|
Great deal
Used 2025 MAZDA CX-50 2.5 S Preferred |
|||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||
$1,267 above avg of $26,859
26,216 miles below avg of 29,140
26,216 miles below avg of 29,140
VIN:
7MMVABBM1SN366179
Type:
Used
Engine:
I4
MPG:
--
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
24 mi
Interior Color:
Gray
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
SUV
Drivetrain:
AWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
567 Colman Street, New London, Connecticut 06320
Last indexed: 4/10/2026
|
Great deal
Used 2024 Hyundai Kona SEL |
|||||||||||
|
|
|
||||||||||
$282 above avg of $23,715
29,969 miles below avg of 34,815
29,969 miles below avg of 34,815
VIN:
KM8HCCAB1RU073505
Type:
Used
Engine:
I4
MPG:
--
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
24 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
SUV
Drivetrain:
AWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
452 Broad Street, New London, Connecticut 06320
Last indexed: 4/15/2026
|
Great deal
Used 2025 Dodge Durango R/T Plus |
|||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||
$1,987 above avg of $44,506
20,313 miles below avg of 22,878
20,313 miles below avg of 22,878
VIN:
1C4SDJCT2SC529590
Type:
Used
Engine:
V8
MPG:
14 / 22
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
24 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
Cloth
Body Style:
SUV
Drivetrain:
AWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
475 Broad Street, New London, Connecticut 06320
Last indexed: 4/17/2026
|
Great deal
Certified 2025 Mercedes-Benz E-Class E 350 4MATIC |
|||||||||||
|
|
|
||||||||||
$10,152 below avg of $62,894
6,475 miles below avg of 9,533
6,475 miles below avg of 9,533
VIN:
W1KLF4HB4SA096016
Type:
Certified
Engine:
I4
MPG:
24 / 33
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
24 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
Sedan
Drivetrain:
AWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
488 Colman Street, New London, Connecticut 06320
Last indexed: 4/13/2026
|
Great deal
Used 2023 Mercedes-Benz Sprinter 4500 |
|||||||||||
|
|
|
||||||||||
$8,431 below avg of $65,431
627 miles below avg of 883
627 miles below avg of 883
VIN:
W1X9N33Y8PN270554
Type:
Used
Engine:
I4
MPG:
--
Fuel:
Diesel
Bed:
--
Distance:
24 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
Van
Drivetrain:
RWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
488 Colman Street, New London, Connecticut 06320
Last indexed: 4/15/2026
|
Great deal
Used 2025 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 4WD Crew Cab Short Bed LT with 2FL |
|||||||||||
|
|
|
||||||||||
$3,281 above avg of $42,439
10,971 miles below avg of 12,055
10,971 miles below avg of 12,055
VIN:
3GCPKKEK2SG140189
Type:
Used
Engine:
I4
MPG:
17 / 20
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
Short
Distance:
24 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
Truck
Drivetrain:
4WD
Cabin:
Crew
Address:
452 Broad Street, New London, Connecticut 06320
Last indexed: 4/14/2026
|
Great deal
Used 2025 Hyundai Venue SEL |
|||||||||||
|
|
|
||||||||||
$492 below avg of $21,272
12,403 miles below avg of 15,577
12,403 miles below avg of 15,577
VIN:
KMHRC8A38SU368245
Type:
Used
Engine:
I4
MPG:
--
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
24 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
Wagon
Drivetrain:
FWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
452 Broad Street, New London, Connecticut 06320
Last indexed: 4/15/2026
|
Great deal
Certified 2025 Ford Ranger Raptor |
|||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||
$601 above avg of $57,292
5,719 miles below avg of 6,906
5,719 miles below avg of 6,906
VIN:
1FTER4LR3SLE38879
Type:
Certified
Engine:
V6
MPG:
16 / 18
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
Short
Distance:
24 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
Leather
Body Style:
Truck
Drivetrain:
4WD
Cabin:
Crew
Address:
475 Broad Street, New London, Connecticut 06320
Last indexed: 4/17/2026
|
Great deal
Certified 2024 Chevrolet Trax LT |
|||||||||||
|
|
|
||||||||||
$1,177 above avg of $22,118
26,583 miles below avg of 30,871
26,583 miles below avg of 30,871
VIN:
KL77LHE29RC017449
Type:
Certified
Engine:
I3
MPG:
28 / 32
Fuel:
Gasoline
Bed:
--
Distance:
20 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
Cloth
Body Style:
Wagon
Drivetrain:
FWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
1320 Old Country Road, Riverhead, New York 11901
Last indexed: 4/15/2026
|
Great deal
Used 2024 BMW i5 M60 |
|||||||||||
|
|
|
||||||||||
$3,523 below avg of $64,523
13,299 miles below avg of 17,733
13,299 miles below avg of 17,733
VIN:
WBY43FK06RCP96496
Type:
Used
Engine:
Electric
MPG:
--
Fuel:
Electric
Bed:
--
Distance:
11 mi
Interior Color:
Black
Interior Type:
--
Body Style:
Sedan
Drivetrain:
AWD
Cabin:
--
Address:
35 Montauk Highway, Southampton, New York 11968
Last indexed: 4/14/2026